Digital health leaders Eren Bali, the co-founder of Carbon Health and founder of Udemy, and Andy Page, the president of Everlywell, made predictions for the future of healthcare after Covid-19.
Summary List PlacementSome of healthcare’s problems are so complex that even the most well-funded startups struggle to fix them.
Carbon Health cofounder and CEO Eren Bali found out as much as his company tried to make prices for doctor’s visits, routine procedures like blood tests, and comparative prices for diagnostic tools like MRIs and x-rays transparent for patients, a feat that sounded simple at first but quickly ballooned into a much larger, systemic problem.
In a Twitter thread posted on December 27, Bali ran through the challenges he and his team had identified in trying to create a menu of sorts for different procedures and treatments for Carbon Health patients.
In the end, he ultimately said the fix lies with insurance companies — not healthcare providers — to fix the way patients and clinics are expected to pay for healthcare in the United States.
“The problem is on the payer side,” Bali told Business Insider. “The payer systems are old and antiquated, and that’s opaque to providers. We are doing all we can on the provider side.”
Read more: $1.5 billion digital-health startup Ro wants to be your online doctor. Here’s how its coronavirus response rooted in rapid at-home testing fits into the new unicorn’s long-term strategy.
Calculating prices ahead of visits proved difficult
Carbon Health serves a wide variety of patients with its urgent and primary care services. It offers booking through an app, and also added virtual visits to any patient seeking care but hesitant or unable to go into one of its physical clinics.
Ideally, Bali said, Carbon would be able to show patients the costs of these services upfront so that the doctor and patient can decide on the best course of treatment together, but hasn’t made as much progress as he would like.
Some relatively new healthcare entrants like Walmart have similar ambitions in making shopping for healthcare just as easy as shopping for groceries. Patients can find Walmart’s cash prices online, such as a primary care visit that costs $40.
Carbon Health has developed a system that works well for patients without insurance, Bali said, because pricing is more straightforward. It created a data analysis tool that looks at different inputs such as existing conditions, Carbon’s cost of service, and other factors to provide an up-front cost to uninsured patients, Bali said. For example, Carbon charges uninsured patients $195 for a primary care sick visit and $69 for a virtual visit, according to its website.
But it was when that same system was trained for patients with insurance that things started to unravel, Bali said. The calculated costs for patients with similar backgrounds, insurance plans, and symptoms only matched 40% of the time, Bali said.
“We can’t explain the difference,” Bali said.
Insurance companies are built on out-dated systems
Part of the variance can be explained by how complex insurance plans are, Bali said. Each plan is essentially unique to the individual that has it, and coverage can range widely even among similar plans offered by the same insurance company.
That’s not something that even the most sophisticated data analytics model can fix, Bali explained. If healthcare providers like Carbon want to tell patients how much they can expect to pay for a visit and associated procedures, insurance companies need to update how they bill both patients and providers.
“It’s driven around the inadequate system,” Angela Miles, head of revenue cycle at Carbon Health, told Business Insider. “We need to rebuild that from a payer standpoint to get to a more modern standpoint.”
More complexity leads to increased costs
Startups like Oscar Health are already attempting to bring insurance companies into a more modern model, Bali said, but larger companies have yet to shift in a meaningful way.
Those that do change, albeit in a more superficial way, actually make the problem worse by making it even more complicated, Bali said, because the added complexity adds time, which adds costs.
“A lot of work that goes towards decreasing healthcare costs is making the system more complicated,” Bali said. “My theory is that things that drive increased cost in healthcare is due to increasing complexity because you can’t be transparent and compete on price.”SEE ALSO: The founder of a healthcare venture fund that just raised $200 million shares why she wants to back founders that are building businesses for their communities
Join the conversation about this story » NOW WATCH: Warren Buffett lives in a modest house that’s worth .001% of his total wealth
Last month, Dentsu introduced a formal healthcare offering, Dentsu Health, that connects expert healthcare marketers to clients. Dentsu Health will be another vertical for Dentsu Solutions, next to Dentsu Creative and Dentsu Media. One of its first client relationships involves working on a Covid-19 vaccination campaign. Getting the “best kept secret” out The offering fits…